|
Themeless by Desire [web]
[nfo]
|
||||||||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
|
|||||||||||||
|
popularity : 58% |
|||||||||||||
alltime top: #30520 |
|
|||||||||||||
|
||||||||||||||
| added on the 2026-11-15 00:03:40 by Heaven/TQA |
||||||||||||||
popularity helper
comments
Yet another demo by Claude :(
.
Your own production is better than claude production any time because it's made by yourself as a human and a artist, Claude is no artist. I am very sorry too say that this hole production is pointless and boring in my eyes because of Claude, use your imagination instead of Claude and come up with something unique from your head please!
But ok to be fair, the pixel artwork is wonderful! And I love the music too! But boring that you used Claude instead of your head in this production.
Like the pxls, liked the music, glenzes, shade bobs.
Well, the commont Amiga from the 90s demo (which I liked a lot).
The landscape scroller is completely unreadable and its BG should - imo - be perhaps black (or dark bleu, as the sea) to make the scroller readable.
But still the Claude is there. And the gfx may - in some way - suffer from that.
At least Heaven, who I respect a lot, is/was honest. That's important.
Well, the commont Amiga from the 90s demo (which I liked a lot).
The landscape scroller is completely unreadable and its BG should - imo - be perhaps black (or dark bleu, as the sea) to make the scroller readable.
Quote:
But ok to be fair, the pixel artwork is wonderful! And I love the music too! But boring that you used Claude instead of your head in this production.
But still the Claude is there. And the gfx may - in some way - suffer from that.
At least Heaven, who I respect a lot, is/was honest. That's important.
sweet
@sim Yes I have to agree that it's better to be honest about using Claude or other AI
tool, than too be sneaky about it. Yes shade bobs me like too and the glenzes I like too. Well this production maybe should have a piggy instead of the thumbs down, when think about it. 🤔
tool, than too be sneaky about it. Yes shade bobs me like too and the glenzes I like too. Well this production maybe should have a piggy instead of the thumbs down, when think about it. 🤔
And i love the Enigma part of course hmm this production is hard one, if it wasn't for the Claude touch i think I would have loved this production more! Hmm 🤔
I’m not going to withhold a thumbs up from a good demo just because the coder decided to use an unconventional (for the moment) debugger tool.
typo: *debugger tool -> debugging tool
@Smaugur:
I dunno. I also hesitated to thumb it down... but..
Well. I think it depends how is the AI stuff is being used.
It is different if it is used to help an experienced (as Heaven surely is) coder to sort some tedious tasks out and speed the lousy work up.
The completely different thing is when it is used from A to Z in 100% by an unknown dude and posted here as result of his "direction" or "hard work".
The scene's true spirit is not about that. And here - Imo - it is not a place to fill the Pouet's DB with such a sloppy slop.
I still think the scene should stay as pure and clean here as possible.
I dunno. I also hesitated to thumb it down... but..
Well. I think it depends how is the AI stuff is being used.
It is different if it is used to help an experienced (as Heaven surely is) coder to sort some tedious tasks out and speed the lousy work up.
The completely different thing is when it is used from A to Z in 100% by an unknown dude and posted here as result of his "direction" or "hard work".
The scene's true spirit is not about that. And here - Imo - it is not a place to fill the Pouet's DB with such a sloppy slop.
I still think the scene should stay as pure and clean here as possible.
@ham yes maybe i made a mistake here, hmm well here is a thumb up for this production even if don't count: 👍 I am sorry guys! You did great!
@sim Yes as clean as possible, I agree with that but to use Claude as a debugging tool, well it's controversial because it's a sport to debug your own code, but it's also eating a lot of time.... Well with that aside, overall I must say I love this production anyway! ❤️
Not a bad use of auto complete, works for me...
Quote:
debugging tool
Well... You are a diplomate here.
A question - is your breakpoint function is "saying" to you
"Ham, not here. I propose you to put the break point here, you gonna find and correct that and that bug"...
"Haaam, the bug is NOT hereeee".
"HAM, THE BUG IS HERE!!, Correct this mnemonic and velue HERE" ;)
Nope. ;)
It is not about playing withing and with bugs, neither.
Well, the scene will never be the same.
And ofcourse, Desire members will not thumb it down. They will not shit into their own nest.
Imagine if this was made by people.
Gaspar still rulez !
Nice Ideas. But I still wonder, if somewhere in time, PoKey music will also be put to that level in such demos.
Nice Ideas. But I still wonder, if somewhere in time, PoKey music will also be put to that level in such demos.
From the SV compo rules:
"It is permissible to use artificial intelligence to generate content in the works, but this should be clearly stated in the comment, and information about this will be placed on the board preceding the presentation."
and reality:
https://www.youtube.com/live/sD4Avkvm2-o?si=JRYi8jmk135-Spmr&t=4545
Strange how my respect towards those talented people shifts towards disappointment, seeing this. I am glad I did not contribute with an honest entry in such a dirty competition. Thumb down for the attitude and towards the party organizers to let this happen.
"It is permissible to use artificial intelligence to generate content in the works, but this should be clearly stated in the comment, and information about this will be placed on the board preceding the presentation."
and reality:
https://www.youtube.com/live/sD4Avkvm2-o?si=JRYi8jmk135-Spmr&t=4545
Strange how my respect towards those talented people shifts towards disappointment, seeing this. I am glad I did not contribute with an honest entry in such a dirty competition. Thumb down for the attitude and towards the party organizers to let this happen.
Thank you Heaven for your answer(s).
I do appreciate.
You wrote as well
If you knew so why you were doint this in that way?
No offenses, but might be the "proffessional part" in some way activated here?
You know, how is it (often) in the business... Very often it is "Do not tell the (whole) truth, otherwise we not gonna make it." Sigh...
Yes, true. But well, personally, I am not gonna buy it.
It - in some way - spoils my (nice) memories from the 90s.
But well, that's my point of view.
Oh, and what 5o5 stated. =/
Have a nice day.
I do appreciate.
You wrote as well
Quote:
I knew I will be slated.
If you knew so why you were doint this in that way?
No offenses, but might be the "proffessional part" in some way activated here?
You know, how is it (often) in the business... Very often it is "Do not tell the (whole) truth, otherwise we not gonna make it." Sigh...
Quote:
...so you see a lot of references to the 90s.
Yes, true. But well, personally, I am not gonna buy it.
It - in some way - spoils my (nice) memories from the 90s.
But well, that's my point of view.
Oh, and what 5o5 stated. =/
Have a nice day.
Heaven, thank you, that is a good move.
I really liked it, it’s a lovely piece of work
Quote:
I’m not going to withhold a thumbs up from a good demo just because the coder decided to use an unconventional (for the moment) debugger tool.
Have you ever tried reading what you’ve written? This text you wrote is for someone who normally shuns AI use, but they can live with it in this particular case. Not for someone who religiously thumbs up every piece of AI slop, true death cult style glazed-over eyes, “as if his whole pension was invested in Nvidia stock”®.
@Heaven:
All good. Thank you for your patience and your answer.
It was not too EZ to express myself here precisely in 100% cosidering this medium (which does not let us to express all the aspects, especially when important subjects are being touched).
Well... I think we are not gonna "run away" from the AI in this area anyway (thinking...).
Quote:
so sorry if I get off record and don't get your question correctly.
All good. Thank you for your patience and your answer.
It was not too EZ to express myself here precisely in 100% cosidering this medium (which does not let us to express all the aspects, especially when important subjects are being touched).
Well... I think we are not gonna "run away" from the AI in this area anyway (thinking...).
Nice effect show!
ok one, mostly an effect show tho :)
You're a good person heaven and I followed what you did in the last years and some of your productions are really impressive.
Still I really can only vote what you've done on your own, because for me scene = handcraft (yes, we use tools but we don't bring a robot arm to the painting class which makes the strokes for us, or do we?), and that makes it a piggie in the end.
Still I really can only vote what you've done on your own, because for me scene = handcraft (yes, we use tools but we don't bring a robot arm to the painting class which makes the strokes for us, or do we?), and that makes it a piggie in the end.
The final effect is nice. The amount of use of AI is hard to tell really, also not really my concern.
AI
Graphics are nice!!
Nobody except Heaven can tell to what extend AI was used. Does it matter? I don't know. I would say it matters less then more, but of course credits are a MUST. To me AI becomes more or less a normal part of the dev chain.
At the end not a single new or innovative effect in this presentation. I liked the "the big wobbly scroller" the most but everything else was just random 90s effects. Not bad, but not exciting either. So I guess thats the reasons for me to say "piggy".
Nobody except Heaven can tell to what extend AI was used. Does it matter? I don't know. I would say it matters less then more, but of course credits are a MUST. To me AI becomes more or less a normal part of the dev chain.
At the end not a single new or innovative effect in this presentation. I liked the "the big wobbly scroller" the most but everything else was just random 90s effects. Not bad, but not exciting either. So I guess thats the reasons for me to say "piggy".
The amount of gatekeeping and hypocrisy in the demoscene never seizes to amaze me.
Quote:
The amount of gatekeeping and hypocrisy in the demoscene never seizes to amaze me.
And who said that...
Pfff.
You can never stop progress from happening, even in the demoscene..
This is something to think about: Transparency of using AI in the code can backfire by fostering a blaming culture that discourages honesty.
And Heaven is honest here, And that is at least worth a piggy in my opinion, but I would have give this production a thumb up because I think this production really deserves that.
And Heaven is honest here, And that is at least worth a piggy in my opinion, but I would have give this production a thumb up because I think this production really deserves that.
Quote:
Transparency of using AI in the code can backfire by fostering a blaming culture that discourages honesty.
No, you use a tool for something that is inherently creative and it goes against the spirit of the forerunners of the scene (the warez/cracktro scene no less, who are 100% against capitalism, etc), you deal with the consequences.
I really like this production and nice to see that Heaven is still around doing code.
AI, no, thank you, sorry
But thank you also for being honest, at least - it is not so common on this "Calud Code time" on demoscene
But thank you also for being honest, at least - it is not so common on this "Calud Code time" on demoscene
I can't tell you where the border is, because probbly the border is different for every single person.
That's why old good demoscene is just gone - dosen't make sense anymore.
There is somth different - for me absolutelly feelingless and pointless
Whenerver I see AI a event don;t waste my time to watch it. The problem is that is more and more hard to recognize it.
Nothing personal - I will still rewatch your old prods I really like. But this with AI - nope ...
That's why old good demoscene is just gone - dosen't make sense anymore.
There is somth different - for me absolutelly feelingless and pointless
Whenerver I see AI a event don;t waste my time to watch it. The problem is that is more and more hard to recognize it.
Nothing personal - I will still rewatch your old prods I really like. But this with AI - nope ...
It's like, if you think of it as a marathon, how much of it the distance you can travel with a car? Only a little bit? Half of it? And what makes sense for the competition? I mean, I can drive the marathon distance in my car in 20 minutes on a highway. Does that count? Personally, I'm more interested in celebrating human achievement. But of course it's for everyone to decide for themselves.
(of course in this case the car also consumer natural resources, destroys societal structure and employment and might eventually cause our extinction but at least it makes software development easy)
(of course in this case the car also consumer natural resources, destroys societal structure and employment and might eventually cause our extinction but at least it makes software development easy)
The unsustainability of "line drawn" is exactly why it's either/or for me. Either AI or noAI. Any AI. Not because anyone thinks all the use scenarios are the same, or that their value is the same, but because any demarcation line is unsustainable projecting it into the future. Besides, many people don't go all AI, not because they don't want to, but because the model they are currently using is incapable of doing it all by itself, only from prompting. This situation changes almost daily.
It also feels unfair to thumb this up when you made the AI do a bunch of your tasks while at the same time a production like ALFYE/NGC has been developed without AI over the last 3 years (at least it's stated like that in their NFO...). Pouet's voting system is also quite limited of course.
It's still amazing what you did here. Also, with graphics and music it's easier to give credit of course, as coder I can understand why it's hard to give credits to tasks properly.
I also have no definite answer how we could turn this into a set of rules because, as xeen said, it's really quite personal. For me personally, as coder, I just can say it's the handcraft that counts for me. When I started in the art/demoscene > 25 years ago I was always amazed by the time, struggle, ambition and dedication those coders put into a production and for me it was always about the question what humans can do with computers - not what computers (LLMs) can do with computers.
It's still amazing what you did here. Also, with graphics and music it's easier to give credit of course, as coder I can understand why it's hard to give credits to tasks properly.
I also have no definite answer how we could turn this into a set of rules because, as xeen said, it's really quite personal. For me personally, as coder, I just can say it's the handcraft that counts for me. When I started in the art/demoscene > 25 years ago I was always amazed by the time, struggle, ambition and dedication those coders put into a production and for me it was always about the question what humans can do with computers - not what computers (LLMs) can do with computers.
OK what do you want? I can't give you any more thumbdowns. I wish I could, but sorry, I can't. If you want to continue raising this controversy, go ahead, release more. After all
Quote:
this is what it's all about. This is what you care about. About yourself. Not about "the scene". I understand. Sauron's ring gave you power that was unattainable before, and you won't let go of it. But not everyone will love you for it.unleashed productivity like never seen before even for my own demos
Quote:
Sauron's ring gave you power that was unattainable before, and you won't let go of it.
This comparaison is really interesting...
Using AI you increase your productivity - of course. The question is what demoscene is about for who. I can give you two examples. One - demomakers. If I use demomaker my productivity increase? Yes. Do I really expect someone admire it? Nope. AI is the best demomaker problably and will be better and better. Second example. I can imagine robot who perfecttly plays on piano Chopin or smt vs young person who spend whole life nd train it and play almost perfect but whith some natural emotions. What do I like? Of course real person. What do you like? If demoscene goes into design only you don't need atari, zx spectrum or amiga for it. Animations are enough. For me demoscene is dead. If you still like it and ues AI - do it, HEaven. There is a chance a lot of people will. But for me and a lot of people like me it is over. There will be something different - AI happenings or whatever we can call it - you can still call it demoscene - it doesn't change anything
Quote:
Regarding the Fractal Flight. people knowing me is that since decades I want to do it but i always hit the last final maths barrier (and I did some 3d stuff on A8 already). Prototypes already existed etc and now finally i can cross it from the bucket list... faster, larger viewport, interactive....
This was a very important and honest sentence for me. And from what I can say, I so much prefer a Heaven who struggles and eventually fails or not - so be it, it's all very likeable.
If an AI model solves this for you, can you really cross it from your bucket list?
a lot of attitude (the right kind), funky pixels and a killer soundtrack.
Quote:
I can only say with 55+ years old AI saves me a lot time and unleashed productivity like never seen before even for my own demos.
The problem is that that productivity comes at the expense of everybody around you. Please read up on the impact LLMs are having on the environment, the internet, and society as a whole. Sure, LLMs solve real problems for real people. As did whale oil, asbestos, and lignite. There are reasons why we eventually decided that in the vast majority of cases, the costs don't justify the benefits of those. Except we did so only once it was too late. Let's not repeat the same mistakes with LLMs.
nice one
Interesting.
I mean.. you could've done it without the slop
Quote:
Quote:I can only say with 55+ years old AI saves me a lot time and unleashed productivity like never seen before even for my own demos.
The problem is that that productivity comes at the expense of everybody around you. Please read up on the impact LLMs are having on the environment, the internet, and society as a whole. Sure, LLMs solve real problems for real people. As did whale oil, asbestos, and lignite. There are reasons why we eventually decided that in the vast majority of cases, the costs don't justify the benefits of those. Except we did so only once it was too late. Let's not repeat the same mistakes with LLMs.
This doesn't seem to matter because '"tool" = fun! :D' and it seems doing the work was never a motivator at all for these people.
AI puke.
This whole "demo" just feels wrong.
This whole "demo" just feels wrong.
AI
I am very saddened by the whole smear campaign against Heaven, as he has been a respected member of the demoscene since the 1990s. I do not believe that the entire codebase was created just using AI; besides, anyone who knows Heaven is well aware of his skills. It is easy to dismiss an entire demo by simply saying, "Oh, come on, it’s an AI-generated demo." Let’s also not forget that a demo consists of graphics and music as well—in this case, there is a wonderful piece of art by Gaspar and excellent music by Maze.
We need to find a way to address this kind of "AI assistance" at demoparties. It is something "new" for us—a challenge that organizers of other events will also have to face—and we will be keeping a close eye on the situation. For now, there are no simple solutions.
We need to find a way to address this kind of "AI assistance" at demoparties. It is something "new" for us—a challenge that organizers of other events will also have to face—and we will be keeping a close eye on the situation. For now, there are no simple solutions.
@grey: things are getting mixed up here. Some people are downthumbing just because AI; some because the AI use wasn’t disclosed in the compo itself. In my case it’s both, but this shouldn’t be taken as a personal attack on the author.
The second point could be solved by adhering to your own compo rules. It seems what has happened is some people AI disclosed on a submission form, and some in their NFO. If people did the latter, the info didn’t end up on the slides.
So either get rid of the “disclosure on slides” rule and make it a free for all, or check the nfo to ensure all relevant info is on the slide (including “no AI disclosed” when relevant). That would be transparent and people can then make their choices (authors AND voters).
The second point could be solved by adhering to your own compo rules. It seems what has happened is some people AI disclosed on a submission form, and some in their NFO. If people did the latter, the info didn’t end up on the slides.
So either get rid of the “disclosure on slides” rule and make it a free for all, or check the nfo to ensure all relevant info is on the slide (including “no AI disclosed” when relevant). That would be transparent and people can then make their choices (authors AND voters).
Nice prod with cool fractal engine!
I'm really torn on this one. On the one hand, I like and respect Heaven, and I'm so sad for him. I appreciate the honesty, as many would just silently use AI without revealing it. Especially old legends like Heaven: I see nothing there that he couldn't have done himself; I wouldn't have suspected any AI use if he hadn't revealed it. This man has been delivering kick-ass 3D engines and has been driven by a passion for fractalus since, well, forever. I remember discussing this with him at Revision, and he damn well knows what he's talking about, no chatbot needed. On the other hand, I wonder why AI then? The answer seems to be productivity. I totally understand the "I paid my share to the demoscene, now I'm getting old and there are still many things on my to-do list" feeling. This goes way beyond the demoscene when you are 50+. Picking what you'll keep doing, what you'll abandon, or where you'll take shortcuts is a real struggle, not to mention what your body forces you to stop doing anyways. So you can choose to do less the old way and be at peace with the lower productivity and the frustration of swallowing the "I'll never do that", or you can decide to use some help and still have fun. What you do for yourself, and what you owe yourself is obviously a personal decision, fuck the world. Now, what you owe to others is the next question; at least what you do for yourself shouldn't harm others. Some consider that using AI is killing the scene, and thus harming them. I believe it's hard to set the cursor of when assistance becomes harmful as discussed supra in this thread. My personal choice is to accept doing less, but proving to myself that I can still do it. But I have to deal with the "you'll never do that in your life, it's over dude" syndrome. Believe me it's h.a.r.d, after all it's being satisfied with sinking slowly enough, but it's what fits my personality. It's a personal choice, I can't blame people for taking the other path, provided it's "some" help from AI, not fully vibe coded. I have no clear opinion about where the "some" cursor should be. So in the end, I cowardly give no strong opinion. Maybe it means that the problem is more complex than all white or all black. Love to everyone.
Quote:
I am very saddened by the whole smear campaign against Heaven, as he has been a respected member of the demoscene since the 1990s.
It's not a smear campaign when it's true. Use tech that is under a heated debate and deal with the consequences imo. I do think it was not malicious, and the way Heaven has explained everything speaks for him, but it doesn't change the use of a technique people just severely dislike and will be vocal about.
Grey is right.
Please do not resort to tired talking points that have already been refuted innumerable times. It just makes you look silly, which I hope you are not.
Indeed. Why do (some of) you guys first seem to take things with grace, then you can’t help but resort to the same falacies that radiate that “evil, lying child type of cunning”. Which just makes people cringe. It’s like this drug twists your personalities. If you follow this “playbook of the dumb”, of course you will release the ST intro.
If you're a programmer, you know if the difference between autocomplete and a thing that writes your code for you.
I have a feeling I'll be getting a lot of glops out of the silly venture! Just waiting on those AI ports of amiga demos and some game to atari Jaguar, it'll be a glop feast!!
Nice effects for an Atari XL, I should test on mine.
@Heaven if you took pleasure creating that demo (in any way), then this is the most important thing.
@Heaven if you took pleasure creating that demo (in any way), then this is the most important thing.
Quote:
I have a feeling I'll be getting a lot of glops out of the silly venture! Just waiting on those AI ports of amiga demos and some game to atari Jaguar, it'll be a glop feast!!
Anyone who wants to claim the ethical and moral high ground should consider whether glop farming is an activity they want to engage in.
Quote:
Anyone who wants to claim the ethical and moral high ground should consider whether glop farming is an activity they want to engage in.
Many people commented stuff like "Glop" on Hugi Issues and Ǝ-МᏩΛꞨᏆИ and I didn't see too much of a fuss raised there.
I like it, really cool demo – cheers, Heaven!
@Heaven: Man, what a mess this whole thread has become. :/
I really respect what you've been doing for the Atari scene all these years. And I enjoyed reading about all those old ideas you finally managed to bring to life. Especially the Fractal Flight!
You were honest about using Claude. You explained what you did and how you did it. People can disagree about AI, sure. But does that really justify all this shit?
And please, don't give up on publishing your ST intro here just because of this circus. I'd much rather see another production from you than another hundred angry comments about AI. :D
Keep doing your stuff, keep experimenting and most importantly, keep having fun with it!
Cheers!
I really respect what you've been doing for the Atari scene all these years. And I enjoyed reading about all those old ideas you finally managed to bring to life. Especially the Fractal Flight!
You were honest about using Claude. You explained what you did and how you did it. People can disagree about AI, sure. But does that really justify all this shit?
And please, don't give up on publishing your ST intro here just because of this circus. I'd much rather see another production from you than another hundred angry comments about AI. :D
Keep doing your stuff, keep experimenting and most importantly, keep having fun with it!
Cheers!
I like the idea of emptying out that ever growing todo list! The ironman part which is somewhat similar to a part in Roots 2 on Amiga is something I'd like to code one day too :)
submit changes
if this prod is a fake, some info is false or the download link is broken,
do not post about it in the comments, it will get lost.
instead, click here !

-------------------
pressented at Silly Venture 2026 Winter Edition
Platform: Atari XL/XE PAL, Single POKEY, 320kb XRAM
Credits:
Loading Screen: +ADAM+
Pixel Artwork: Gaspar, Premium, Hammerfist, Robin
Airon Man Sprite: Ooz, taken from the demo Level by Agenda and "Airon maned"
Music Soundtrack: mAze in double VBL Speed, single POKEY
Ideas, Project Lead, Code: Heaven, Claude
Tooling, Debugging, Optimisations: Claude
All effects loaded from RAM-banks for seamless playback, all use 64kb only.
https://youtu.be/nZBhjkvvD5I