pouët.net

Go to bottom

Oldschool demos getting vendor locked?

category: general [glöplog]
yzi: so you claim that current tech wont become oldskool platforms?
Quote:
They still have PCs. Evne if they don't buy new ones as much, or don't use them as much, they still have them, and these PCs still run Windows. Phones and tablets don't replace PCs, they just allow you to do some of the things you needed a PC for, while being on the move.

Well, if people don't use PCs with Windows as much anymore, then they don't play as many games on that platform as before. That means the market for Windows games is shrinking which means Windows is getting less relevant.

Quote:
Content creation and DAW perhaps (I don't know much about either on linux tbh), but gaming and dev? It's not like valve is a small games company, and they're taking linux gaming very seriously :D And linux is *very* heavily used for dev work.


Quote:
Linux may be used for dev work, by misguided souls (just as most open source software is developed by misguided souls).

That is a ridiculous thing to say. Both Windows and Linux is used by extremely brilliant people. You sound a lot like a Windows fanboy.

Quote:
By that reasoning, there is still a typewriter market, where some typewriter maker (which perhaps disappeared years ago :) still dominates the market. Because those typewriters still exist :D

Haha! I quite like that analogy.
added on the 2014-02-19 16:43:38 by paldepind paldepind
Quote:
- Are the VIC + SID chips (and anything else I guess) well known enough now to make 100% compatible clones, or emulate them (either ASIC or FPGA or software)?

At least for the 6502 there had been a fantastic effort to convert a hi-res die shot into a polygon model which allowed to emulate it on a transistor level (presentation on YouTube). A similar effort by the same people seems to be underway for the SID chip. So there's hope for 100% compatible clones. :)
added on the 2014-02-19 16:48:37 by Kylearan Kylearan
blender in linux vs 3dsmax or maya on windows/mac.
reaper in linux vs cubase or logic on windows/mac.
gimp in linux vs photoshop on windows/mac.

yeah! linux rules for content creation, just like a using a cheese grater to scratch your balls rules. ;)
Quote:
Problem is, nobody takes Valve seriously.

Yeah, they're just a small and insignificant company. Who cares about them?
added on the 2014-02-19 16:53:23 by cruzer cruzer
Quote:
No, because people still use PCs, just not as much as they used to perhaps. People don't use typewriters anymore.


People use them less, and for fewer tasks, and eventually not at all. It's the same :D Well, not quite - typewriters died out, I don't see that happening to PCs any time soon. Still, the market shrinks.

Quote:
No, some people just claim it is, based on sales figures. Gargaj already answered that.
It's the same with cars. Because of the crisis, people buy less new cars. Instead, they use their current car longer before buying new. It does not mean that people use cars less.


Are there any usage stats for desktops? I see them sometimes for mobile, but not for desktop (well, there are % share stats, but it's a nightmare to get any useful info from that). The mobile stats show some unexpected things, it'd be interesting to see what the PC side looks like.

Quote:
If you're talking about demos... It's trivial to target both desktop and phone, since you can use the same D3D11 code on both, as long as you keep your shaders simple enough so that the average phone hardware supports it (generally DX9-level).


No, not demos unfortunately - I write photography software (mostly realtime image processing stuff). It makes no sense on a desktop really, you don't have a camera to do cool stuff with.
added on the 2014-02-19 16:58:09 by psonice psonice
Quote:
Well, if people don't use PCs with Windows as much anymore, then they don't play as many games on that platform as before.


That is a non-sequitur.
People don't need PCs as much for tasks that they can do on their phones/tablets. Eg, you don't have to start up your PC just to read your mail, or check your Facebook.
Gaming, at least, the type of gaming traditionally done on PC, is not something that can be done on phones/tablets, so there is no decrease in gaming activity on Windows based on increased phone/tablet usage.

Quote:
That is a ridiculous thing to say. Both Windows and Linux is used by extremely brilliant people. You sound a lot like a Windows fanboy.


I'm an Amiga fanboy. I'm also a realist.

Quote:
Haha! I quite like that analogy.


Yes, broken analogies are just your bag!
added on the 2014-02-19 17:14:44 by Scali Scali
Quote:
People use them less, and for fewer tasks, and eventually not at all.


Again, a non-sequitur.
I don't see phones/tablets replacing ALL tasks that we use a PC for, simply because they have different screen sizes, different user interfaces etc, which just aren't suited for certain tasks.
Heck, I still use a PC for tasks that I *could* do on my phone. I mean, if it's just a quick reply, I can send an email from my phone. But for more serious stuff, I will always prefer to sit down at my PC, and take the time to write a proper mail.

Quote:
I don't see that happening to PCs any time soon.


Exactly

Quote:
Still, the market shrinks.


I don't think so. Even if there's only one task that you still need a PC for, the PC market will survive. In fact, I would say that PCs are actually becoming MORE important. More and more stuff, eg government-related is being automated, so you NEED a PC to do your taxes and various other things.
Again, it is highly unlikely that people are ever going to do their taxes on their phone, even if it were possible (currently there's no app for phones anyway). They would rather sit down at a PC, and take their time to do it right.
added on the 2014-02-19 17:21:15 by Scali Scali
In fact, my mother got her first PC a few years ago for that very reason. I think that actually goes for quite a few people, especially older people.
They now want/need email to keep in touch with family, and they need internet access so they can do online banking (they used to just go to a bank and fill out a form etc. You have to do most stuff online now). Also things like reporting gas/electric usage... all done via computers these days.
And mostly things that are too important to do on a phone with a small screen and clumsy interface, if it can be done at all.
added on the 2014-02-19 17:30:39 by Scali Scali
Quote:
That is a non-sequitur.
People don't need PCs as much for tasks that they can do on their phones/tablets. Eg, you don't have to start up your PC just to read your mail, or check your Facebook.
Gaming, at least, the type of gaming traditionally done on PC, is not something that can be done on phones/tablets, so there is no decrease in gaming activity on Windows based on increased phone/tablet usage.


Um, wasn't the mobile game market almost as big as the PC market already? I'm pretty sure it's predicted to pass it in the next few years.

There are of course the "casual" market and the "hardcore" markets for games. I can see phones + tablets wiping out the casual side on the PC through pure convenience. The serious side, we'll have to see. The devices are getting a lot more powerful, devs are getting a lot better at touch-based controls (hopefully no more on-screen d-pads ;) and the manufacturers are creating standards for controllers. It's not happening yet, but don't rule it out.

Apart from that, there's a big cost issue here. If I buy a PC, I'll happily spend a bit more on it so it plays games well. But if I'm not buying a PC because I don't really use it now except for games, it's suddenly a very expensive games console. Will people still buy them, or will they move to consoles?
added on the 2014-02-19 17:33:15 by psonice psonice
Quote:
In fact, my mother got her first PC a few years ago for that very reason. I think that actually goes for quite a few people, especially older people.
They now want/need email to keep in touch with family, and they need internet access so they can do online banking (they used to just go to a bank and fill out a form etc. You have to do most stuff online now). Also things like reporting gas/electric usage... all done via computers these days.
And mostly things that are too important to do on a phone with a small screen and clumsy interface, if it can be done at all.


You know, *all* of that can be done on a tablet. Most of it on a phone (certainly banking, electric readings etc.). I did my taxes recently, on a laptop, but I'm sure I could have done it just fine on my iPad too. There's a good enough spreadsheet app on there, the electronic submission is through a website. The only part i can see being slightly annoying is typing, but I have a cheap bluetooth keyboard.

My own perspective on this, as it happens, also comes in a big part from my mother :) She had a desktop and a laptop. Both were getting a bit old. So when my wife upgraded her laptop, we gave her the old one (which was still pretty good). I also gave her an old iPad 2 I wasn't using (I have to buy almost every iPhone + iPad for testing).

A few months later I visited and asked how she was finding the new computer. She hadn't used it in weeks, because the iPad was there, it was more convenient, and it did everything she needed. In fact she decided to buy a new iPad mini with 3G so she could carry it around with her.
added on the 2014-02-19 17:44:59 by psonice psonice
Quote:
Quote:
Well, if people don't use PCs with Windows as much anymore, then they don't play as many games on that platform as before.

That is a non-sequitur.

No that is most certainly not a non-sequitur. Unless you want me to believe that the massive amount of games played on tablets and phones has not any impact at all on how much people game on PCs.

Quote:
People don't need PCs as much for tasks that they can do on their phones/tablets.

Oh. You mean like casually playing games in the comfort of your living room?
added on the 2014-02-19 17:49:53 by paldepind paldepind
Quote:
Um, wasn't the mobile game market almost as big as the PC market already? I'm pretty sure it's predicted to pass it in the next few years.


How is that relevant? As I already said, different types of games, they don't compete with eachother.

Quote:
There are of course the "casual" market and the "hardcore" markets for games. I can see phones + tablets wiping out the casual side on the PC through pure convenience. The serious side, we'll have to see. The devices are getting a lot more powerful, devs are getting a lot better at touch-based controls (hopefully no more on-screen d-pads ;) and the manufacturers are creating standards for controllers. It's not happening yet, but don't rule it out.


I think mobile gaming would threaten consoles first... That is, if you can hook your phone/tablet up to a bunch of wireless controllers and your TV.

Quote:
Apart from that, there's a big cost issue here. If I buy a PC, I'll happily spend a bit more on it so it plays games well. But if I'm not buying a PC because I don't really use it now except for games, it's suddenly a very expensive games console. Will people still buy them, or will they move to consoles?


Consoles have been around longer than PCs have. So far, consoles never killed PC gaming.
Again, console gaming and PC gaming are not quite the same thing. There are plenty of discussions online on how keyboard and mouse beats a controller for FPS, and all that.
added on the 2014-02-19 17:51:59 by Scali Scali
Quote:
You know, *all* of that can be done on a tablet. Most of it on a phone (certainly banking, electric readings etc.). I did my taxes recently, on a laptop, but I'm sure I could have done it just fine on my iPad too. There's a good enough spreadsheet app on there, the electronic submission is through a website. The only part i can see being slightly annoying is typing, but I have a cheap bluetooth keyboard.


Not in my country. There's a Windows, linux and OS X binary. So you could only theoretically do it on a Windows 8 tablet.
And as I say, even if you could, it'd be far more comfortable to do with a PC.
added on the 2014-02-19 17:54:33 by Scali Scali
Quote:
No that is most certainly not a non-sequitur. Unless you want me to believe that the massive amount of games played on tablets and phones has not any impact at all on how much people game on PCs.


It is.
Look at some of the most popular mobile games... Eg Angry Birds. That's not popular AT ALL on Windows.
Ergo, Angry Birds' popularity on mobile platforms has not eaten into the PC gaming market.
Look at the top selling games in the Play Store, and compare them to the top selling games on eg Steam. Massively different types of games.
added on the 2014-02-19 17:58:57 by Scali Scali
[quote]How is that relevant? As I already said, different types of games, they don't compete with each other.[quote]

But of course they do. PCs are better at 'hardcore' type games, mobile devices are better at casual, but there's a LOT of overlap still, because most games are between those extremes.

Quote:
I think mobile gaming would threaten consoles first... That is, if you can hook your phone/tablet up to a bunch of wireless controllers and your TV.


Yeah, I think that is actually likely. The tech is already there (there's apple tv, and some android phones have wireless display support). Wireless controllers already exist. And these things get a lot faster each year while the consoles stay static. At some point the games will be good enough, and the fact that you can walk out with the console in your pocket will make it an easy choice.

Quote:
Consoles have been around longer than PCs have. So far, consoles never killed PC gaming.
Again, console gaming and PC gaming are not quite the same thing. There are plenty of discussions online on how keyboard and mouse beats a controller for FPS, and all that.


Hmm, I don't think that quite works out though. Consoles haven't killed PC gaming, but I think there are a few reasons for that - a big one being "I need a PC". If you need it, you may as well use it for gaming too.

If that has changed and people don't need the PC because they have a tablet, do they still get a PC to play games on? Or do they get a cheaper console? Or just play games on the tablet - it's not like there's a shortage of good games on them.

There's still going to be that part of the market where a keyboard and mouse and a high end system is best of course, but I can see the PC game market shrinking along with the PC market itself.
added on the 2014-02-19 18:10:59 by psonice psonice
Quote:
But of course they do. PCs are better at 'hardcore' type games, mobile devices are better at casual, but there's a LOT of overlap still, because most games are between those extremes.


Really? I had never even *heard* of the term 'casual gaming' until a few years ago, when smartphones and tablets started to become popular.
As far as I know, casual gaming simply did not exist on PC (and still doesn't, really).

Quote:
Hmm, I don't think that quite works out though. Consoles haven't killed PC gaming, but I think there are a few reasons for that - a big one being "I need a PC". If you need it, you may as well use it for gaming too.


Well, perhaps you missed my earlier posts where I explained why I think that PCs will only become more important for everyday tasks.

Quote:
There's still going to be that part of the market where a keyboard and mouse and a high end system is best of course, but I can see the PC game market shrinking along with the PC market itself.


I don't think so, because as I already said: consoles have been around longer than PCs. If consoles didn't make the PC game market shrink (or in fact, prevented the PC gaming market from ever starting), then why would tablets/phones, if they can take over the role of consoles?
added on the 2014-02-19 18:23:37 by Scali Scali
Mobile games.. lol! Real games are on PC, pls.
added on the 2014-02-19 18:40:50 by Serpent Serpent
real games are on C64, obviously.

damn kids
added on the 2014-02-19 18:47:43 by groepaz groepaz
sais the guy who admits being addicted to doom2 ;P
added on the 2014-02-19 18:51:43 by wysiwtf wysiwtf
Scali: what are you smoking? casual gaming has been happening on pc for years, its a big market, think of all the facebook games, and there already were flash game portals even before facebook became hip. plenty of kids and bored house wives randomly searching for free games online. were they any good by hardcore gamers standards? no. but they kept folks entertained for a few minutes and scored some money with advertising banners. the "niche" thrived on pc well before smartphone and tablets became so big.

Serpent: more often i find myself spending my "gaming time" handling my ipad instead of looking at the desktop/laptop/consoles. there is a lot of crap on mobile games for sure, but you can also find some quite nice stuff in there.
added on the 2014-02-19 19:00:11 by psenough psenough
a good demo platform isn't necessarily a good platform in any other sense. picking the most obscure and contrived platform possible can be part of the fun. sure, an audience of outsiders may not understand that, and may not be able to appreciate the technical aspects of it all, but the scene has never been about outsiders (well, i guess you could argue that it largely consists of outsiders in a broader sense). if the people involved in making demos were aiming for world wide recognition they would have picked the wrong hobby, so i think it's hard to argue from that assumption.

only some prods end up being somewhat recognized outside the scene, when their complexity can be appreciated in simple and amazing terms (like "fps in 64k" or "music video in 4k").
added on the 2014-02-19 19:03:46 by linde linde
Quote:
think of all the facebook games


Facebook open to general public: since 2006.
iPhone: since 2007.
Hence:
Quote:
I had never even *heard* of the term 'casual gaming' until a few years ago, when smartphones and tablets started to become popular.
added on the 2014-02-19 19:25:57 by Scali Scali
Quote:
real games are on C64, obviously.

damn kids


Well.. Having been playing games with C64 since 83/84 i have to say, apart from being of course nostalgic, that very very few of them are imho playable today, unfortunately. For me pinnacle of gaming has been 90's and 2k's PC games. But like said, in recent years this "casual" gaming shit has unfortunately been bringing also PC games downwards...
added on the 2014-02-19 19:27:00 by Serpent Serpent
Track 'n' Field on C64 still owns all!
added on the 2014-02-19 19:30:18 by Scali Scali

login

Go to top