pouët.net

Well, a lots of people seems to talk of this demo as if it took their virginity.
Others speak vehemently about this prod, by keeping their "fuck you" :

• [...]has pressed esc.
  
• [...]It looks very ugly.
  
• [...]one good effect (mfx-like)[...].
  
• stop...i dont like it..it is not a real nice prod. [...] is not it a name voting?
  
• this shit! not demo!
  
• crap.
  
• gets more and more overrated. fr groupies from outer space. please, delete that 14x "coup de coeur"[...].
  

So... what is happening exactly ? What makes this demo so polemic ?
And what about the massive CDC aknowledgement ?
Wasn't CDC made to point out unknown prods and give them more attention when it's need ?

i think i've found a good summary of the whole affair which clearly characterizes the bevavior and motives of the people partaking in the discourse about aforementioned demo:

LOL POUET.

one thing is for sure
- it totally silenced the partyplace
like 6 to 7 minutes :)

sleep can have that effect :)

Come on we have to be glad demos like this are being released. You can have a critical view ofcoz but value a demo for its real worth and don't 'pouetize'
to much. FR is releasing demo for years now they can't be all of a very HIGH standart.. Nuance your words and dont be to harsh! long live FR!

(and now give us FR-50 at bp07 and I be happy ;-)

Well, it was a nice demo imo. Just not as nice as the number of CDCs suggest...but of course you realize as you get older that "popular opinion" is pretty meaningless when judging quality. so i should not be surprized. and im not.

names always attract votes. its just a fact of life. nothing to really flame or get upset about, i dont think.

Magic has this weird ability of trying to say something insightful and then ruining by making it inadvertedly biased. Also the sloppy formulation and spelling somehow ruin the message.

"they can't be all of a very HIGH standart" - you are already imposing an opinion by insinuating that fr-055 is a bad demo. In fact most people have been discussing whether they like the demo or not which is on a completely different level.

I also tried to dissect your first two sentences, but they do not make much sense.

Actually I fell asleep watching it (for real), I was thrilled to see that there were a new Farbrausch demo...but my enthusiasm didn't last the entire demo. But I'll try to rewatch it some other day, together with a large bucket of coffee.

I'll put my Coop Decorations where I fucking want to.

End of discussion.

Meh! It's an ok demo, nothing worthy of any controversy or flaming.

I like most farbrausch demos! Also if someone is telling shit about the good ones, I will inform the person about the reality. The reason I thought this was a "coup de coeur" fun hack, is because I was searching for the clue in this production. I'm missing it in a most of the last fr productions.
As I can imagine what makes a crew like fr laugh --> it must have been a fun hack
Don't be angry I'm just writing what I thought. Also if I am retarded.
Nevertheless, some greetz to farbrausch people that perhaps remember me. I think you understand what I mean and won't be angry.
Funny reality is also: If a newbies release something on pouet everybody is shitting on them very proudly as it would be a virtue. So it's not a shame to write what I (you) think about a veterans demo without using vaseline.

I'll put my Coop Decorations where I fucking want to.

End of discussion.

seppjo no newbie released some high quality prod and got shitted on. just give me an example. you aren't making any sense.

about the cdc issue; why are you so annoyed it if you don't value pouet comments anyway?

I believe it has more than any other prod now.

i will pull back my cdc's btw, i was just way bored.

To make it very clear, my opinion is that it is a * very very * good demo, one step further is made thanks to visualice; But I also believe that most people can't understand what exactly happens on the screen because the eye is something you got to learn to use, and few people are actually sensitive about that. We are in a society were images cost nothing. And this demo shows images that cost everything.

If you understand this, you understand that the polemic can't be avoid !

i agree with shane.

i agree with kb_.

by the way, a related question.

should one user be able to give more than one CDC's to a prod?

(asking as the current webmonkey behind pouet)

Also, there is a new page widening exploit on pouet. Just look on this page: http://www.pouet.net/groups.php?which=322.

Its a bit difficult to apply though ;)

Gargaj: Where is the issue with that? There is no CDC ranking.

Gargaj: no, this makes no sense.

Stelthz: no issue, i just wonder if that's semantically a good idea...

Gargaj: good question, I guess it should not be possible indeed coz it doesn't make any sense

Well, it makes no sense. But it pales compared to all the other stuff that does not make any sense on pouet.