pouët.net

Go to bottom
The Final Frontier by Slight
[nfo]
screenshot added by sim on 2026-11-15 12:06:34
platform :
type :
release date : november 2026
release party : Silly Venture 2026
compo : oldskool 256b
ranked : 7th
  • 8
  • 2
  • 5
popularity : 46%
 46%
  • 0.20
alltime top: #86251
added on the 2026-11-15 12:06:32 by sim sim

popularity helper

increase the popularity of this prod by spreading this URL:

or via: facebook twitter pinterest tumblr bluesky threads

comments

Slop.
sucks added on the 2026-11-15 12:30:58 by uncle-x uncle-x
nice
rulez added on the 2026-11-15 12:55:06 by Heaven/TQA Heaven/TQA
I mean, it's a nice effect and all, but when AI is even apparently writing your nfo it leaves a bad taste.
sucks added on the 2026-11-15 17:26:24 by mdr mdr
Yeah, I think somehow the saddest part is the infofile. But slop in any case.
sucks added on the 2026-11-16 10:08:45 by Preacher Preacher
Thus this was not released in a AI Compo... i vote it down.
sucks added on the 2026-11-16 10:20:19 by AMItac_TSA AMItac_TSA
@Heaven/TQA: Thanks for the thumbs up!

To everyone calling this AI slop: I wrote all the 6502 code in this intro myself. AI helped with the .NFO translation and with tests comparing floating-point and fixed-point results.

The longer explanation below is in Polish, so I can say exactly what I mean. Translate it however you like. Yes, you can use AI. :P

Jeśli wpis „GPT/Astra6” w sekcji tools wystarczył, żeby uznać kod tego intra za wygenerowany przez AI, to wyjaśniam: cały kod 6502 tego intra napisałem sam.

Pomysł był prosty: wziąć mój stary program w Atari BASIC-u, przepisać go na asembler 6502 i zmieścić w 256 bajtach. Cała zabawa polegała na zrobieniu tego samemu. Piszę w asemblerze 6502 od ponad 30 lat i właśnie takie dłubanie w kodzie nadal sprawia mi frajdę.

Do czego użyłem AI? Angielski znam na tyle słabo, że przy tłumaczeniu .NFO posiłkowałem się LLM-em. Astra robiła też testy porównujące wyniki obliczeń zmiennoprzecinkowych i stałoprzecinkowych. To były zastosowania, do których odnosił się wpis w sekcji tools. Wymieniłem to narzędzie, bo chciałem uczciwie zaznaczyć jego udział w pracy.

Kod samego intra napisałem sam i dlatego w credits widnieje „code: Seban/Slight”.

Nie każdemu musi się podobać to intro. Możecie krytykować pomysł, efekt czy wykonanie. Ale jeśli zarzut brzmi „ten kod napisało AI”, to dotyczy czegoś, co po prostu nie miało miejsca.

Najbardziej irytuje mnie to, że podaję użyte narzędzie, a potem muszę wyjaśniać, że nie służyło do tego, co ktoś sobie dopowiedział. Zanim przykleicie komuś łatkę „AI slop”, zapytajcie chociaż, do czego właściwie użył AI. Tłumaczenie opisu, porównywanie wyników obliczeń i generowanie kodu to różne zastosowania. Sam wpis w sekcji tools nie mówi, które z nich miało miejsce.

Źródła wrzucę na GitHub, żeby każdy zainteresowany mógł obejrzeć kod. W .NFO doprecyzuję też rolę GPT/Astra6: tłumaczenie tekstu z polskiego na angielski oraz testy porównawcze obliczeń floating point i fixed point.
added on the 2026-11-16 11:56:58 by seban seban
@seban:
FWIW my friend and I watched the stream and didn’t think this release was AI - here’s a thumb for the nice effect :)

Away from this, and an issue that is on the orgas - they should have actually enforced their own rules (that all AI use needed to be declared) and stated on every sllde whether AI was used - or not. I feel really sorry that your prod has been caught in this.
rulez added on the 2026-11-16 12:22:44 by Tom Tom
Please, speak and write in english.
Thank you.
added on the 2026-11-16 12:22:51 by sim sim
human slop
rulez added on the 2026-11-16 12:27:55 by zoi zoi
neat effect, and also what tom said
rulez added on the 2026-11-16 14:44:43 by wbcbz7 wbcbz7
@sim: sorry for the Polish response, but after that misunderstanding I don't feel confident writing in English. My native language is Polish, and my English skills are not so good, so I assumed that I could write in Polish and everyone could translate it into their own language to better understand my statement and thoughts.

In short: in my Polish text, I stated that I did not use AI to generate the code for the intro. Others wrongly assumed that I did. GPT/Astra was used to translate the .nfo file from Polish to English, run precision tests comparing floating-point calculations in the Atari BASIC model with integer calculations in my code, and run regression tests. That's why GPT/Astra was listed in the tools section of the .nfo file.

I will publish all the source code on my GitHub (most of my prods are already there), so everybody can see it and judge for themselves if my word is not enough.

I've been writing code for the 6502 for over 30 years, and I still find it fun and satisfying, so generating the code for such a small intro with an LLM obviously doesn't make any sense to me.
added on the 2026-11-16 15:49:16 by seban seban
Hi Seban =).

Thank you for your kind answer. No hard feeling, you can be sure of that!

I think your English skills are really good enuff, even if subject is delicate and not so evident, to write in EN. Imagine you do not speak the language of the person who is explaing his efforts... Not only it would be insignificant for you but also a simple "blabla" =/.

So thanks for your last, english, post =).

As for the AI usage.
What is important is that ppl are not against you.
You are an extremely expirienced Atari XL coder (with many years... what? over 30 years in 6502asm usage? times flies by soooo FAST?).
The thing is the surprise of using the AI. Especially these days, after many AI incidents lately.

OK. I stop here. Do not want to open another discussion ;)

Once again Seban, thanks for translating (and such, respecting non-PL speakers =).

And hope to see some good Atari prods from you soon!

Cheers.
added on the 2026-11-16 16:27:00 by sim sim
I wonder:
1. What made you think this is AI-generated?
2. Who are you guys? What is your knowledge of Atari 8-bit? Have you ever seen this machine?

In the '90s, I created a popular 6502 assembler xasm, which the very first tool listed by Seban.
Virtually all 8-bit prods are assembler slop.
And Seban is a legend who can speak 6502 machine code, has enormous knowledge of coding and electronics and has taught me a lot.

Hi, Heaven! :)
rulez added on the 2026-11-16 22:18:26 by 0xF 0xF
balancing out the thumbs in what seems to be a major misunderstanding.
rulez added on the 2026-11-16 22:31:34 by dipswitch dipswitch
Nice, i like the effect!
rulez added on the 2026-11-17 08:40:53 by MKM MKM
0xF:
"I wonder:
1. What made you think this is AI-generated?"

Maybe some people are able to read and understand written text?
"Tools: - XASM, Altirra/AltirraSDL + Bridge, Python, GPT-6/Astra."

You can verify floating-point calculations also WITHOUT any "help" from an LLM.
sucks added on the 2026-11-17 11:55:38 by lsl lsl
@lsl: Sure I can! I could even grab a pencil and do it on paper, just for the pleasure of wasting an evening. :D

30+ years of messing with 6502 and I still enjoy it. But sitting there comparing FP and fixed-point numbers by hand? Screw that! I'm 50+, got plenty of other things to do. Let the damn machine do the boring work!

And that little reading lesson you gave 0xF? Funny. Maybe try reading my posts once more. I explained what Astra did. Checking calculations and writing code are two rather different things, you know.

And you know what? I don't think AI is what's killing the demoscene. It's this stupid "AI mentioned? Must be slop!" attitude. No questions, no checking what was actually done. Just point a finger and start shouting. Great way to screw up the scene, guys.

Anyway, enough of this circus. I'm not going to explain it for the hundredth time. :P
added on the 2026-11-17 13:01:39 by seban seban
Yeah, go back to your AI-circus.
Thank you.
"I'm 50+" blabla... WHATEVER!!

"Checking calculations"
It's a fucking starfield, NO ROCKET SCIENCE!!
Do you work for NASA??!

You and your fellow AI-retards screw up the scene.
added on the 2026-11-17 13:15:06 by lsl lsl
@lsl: Exactly! It's just a fucking starfield, not rocket science. So why are you making such a big drama out of a tool I used to check some calculations? :D

I wrote the code. Astra compared the results. That's it. How difficult is that to understand?

So calling people names is your way of saving the demoscene? Brilliant! :P

Have fun!
added on the 2026-11-17 13:40:16 by seban seban
Cool colorcycler!
rulez added on the 2026-11-17 15:28:08 by Zerus Zerus

lists containing this prod

submit changes

if this prod is a fake, some info is false or the download link is broken,

do not post about it in the comments, it will get lost.

instead, click here !

[previous edits]

add a comment

Go to top