pouët.net

Go to bottom

Picture is clearly edited in Photoshop is widely recognized as "the Year photo"

category: gfx [glöplog]
 
Press Photographers reacts strongly that a picture is clearly edited in Photoshop is widely recognized as "the Year photo" of a jury in college Journalists. The photographer thinks it should be allowed to use editing tools to make better pictures.


In the news: Full dispute on winning photo (NRK) - Photographer denies cheating - Fedrelandsvennen

The picture in question:

BB Image

Original: picture:
BB Image


What do you think, should simple editing be allowed when it's obvious alterations?
added on the 2013-11-08 20:51:08 by fluor fluor
I'm all up for photoshop editing... however, neither the picture or the editing on that one is any good
added on the 2013-11-08 20:55:03 by Jcl Jcl
Here's my attempt:


BB Image

Kinda more interesting!
added on the 2013-11-08 21:13:23 by fluor fluor
If the rules of the compo don't forbid the use of photoshop then it's okay, I think. But apart from this I don't like the photo that much and the photoshop-editing looks kinda cheap.
added on the 2013-11-08 21:24:18 by gaspode gaspode
That's an awful photo, and I'm an awful photographer, I should know! I'm also an awful photoshop and those edges on the windows are just bad!
added on the 2013-11-08 21:28:58 by xernobyl xernobyl
BB Image
added on the 2013-11-08 22:11:54 by havoc havoc
Wtf, Osama bin Laden is still alive
added on the 2013-11-09 01:14:36 by Zplex Zplex
added on the 2013-11-09 13:33:46 by baah baah
How can anyone get away with masking their filters several pixels off target?
You can still see the white colored orginal in the edges of the window,.
added on the 2013-11-09 13:44:03 by numtek numtek
Quote:
Maybe I've gone too far by bus.

via Google Translate.
added on the 2013-11-09 15:13:56 by trc_wm trc_wm
I thought the Turner Prize was the biggest load of garbage going O_o
added on the 2013-11-09 15:22:43 by raizor raizor
Meanwhile, at the National Geographic...
BB Image
added on the 2013-11-09 15:22:50 by Zavie Zavie
nice one, Havoc!
added on the 2013-11-09 16:41:14 by fluor fluor
havoc's picture is much more better than the winning one imho...
added on the 2013-11-10 04:19:41 by geralth geralth
what the fuck is that hotdog around his neck?

BB Image
added on the 2013-11-10 05:39:46 by farfar farfar
also... isn't that Maali???
added on the 2013-11-10 06:35:34 by farfar farfar
Yeah, the author of the image clearly photoshopped away the Outline logo, and inverted the colors on the hat!
added on the 2013-11-10 08:58:41 by Puryx Puryx
the Year photo? total crap, both shopped and original? wat?
added on the 2013-11-10 19:10:36 by Serpent Serpent
Quote:
Here's my attempt:


BB Image

Kinda more interesting!


Is that ERNA (Norways version of Angela Merkel) in the back there? :D
added on the 2013-11-11 12:20:40 by tFt tFt
Photoshop is the new darkroom.
added on the 2013-11-11 15:28:27 by Frost Frost
farfar: as it's me, i can tell you it's a rubberduck sausage. i wear rubberduck sausages all the time so my head doesnt snap off. the hat is in case my head does snap off, but at least i dont get scratches from the asphalt or other hard surface on my forehead. i was considering to wear a clown nose to protect my nose as well, but a seagull took and ate it on the way to the bus. i hope that explains everything!
Also, the photo is totally crappy :D
added on the 2013-11-12 15:03:13 by rez rez
If the photographer won with a really crappy photoshop mangle of a really crappy photo, you have to applaud the guy. The jury on the other hand are clearly utterly incompetent and need a good spanking.
added on the 2013-11-12 15:18:08 by psonice psonice
yes, tFt
added on the 2013-11-12 18:36:22 by fluor fluor

login

Go to top